It Sucks to be Wrong

[This is chapter one of my book, Partly Wrong.]

“Huge Lot of Comics and Baseball Memorabilia.”

The Craigslist ad title screamed at me. I think it was 2004. Only 3 years earlier, I had discovered–and joined–this intriguing 6 year old website with a weird name, eBay. It was fascinating, and I tried my hand at selling a few things. Some old radios a neighbor threw out. Boxes of overstock Hallmark ornaments. A huge lot of Broadway playbills someone was giving away on I made some pretty good sales. I wanted to make more.

Some of by best sales were “hidden treasures,” something of value that was being tossed out. I paid almost nothing for it, but I made quite a profit. That is the attraction of selling on eBay. You tell yourself that you are just looking for some good things to sell. The truth is that you are always looking for “the big one.” The picture with some ancient American government document tucked away in the frame. The video game every collector is dying to have. The crappy old snare drum that turns out to be a Ludwig “Black Beauty.” The baseball card that is one of only four known to exist.

“Huge Lot of Comics and Baseball Memorabilia.” My pulse quickened a bit. I dialed the seller, casually asking about the ad. No, the lot had not sold yet, but a lot of people were calling about it. Of course, I could come see it. Why yes, he could even work me in for a visit today. I scribbled down the address, jumped in my van and drove to his town 35 minutes northwest of us. Inching down a two lane road, searching mailbox numbers, I found his drive and turned in. The van followed a dusty gravel road to a large rustic barn just past the main house. A wiry man in his late fifties greeted me with a handshake and smile. Was that a twinkle in his eye…or a glint? I followed him up the back stairs to a loft door. Stepping in out of the sun, I squinted in the darkness. Slowly, box after box after box began to appear on shelves, on tables, on the floor.

“Take your time and look around. Somebody else called and wants to come look at them after a bit.”

I’d better hurry. Where to start? There were endless boxes of sleeved comic books. Dusty boxes held tens of thousands of baseball cards, many indexed by years. I saw a signed baseball or two. Hmm. Looks like “Mickey Mantle” on that baseball. A dusty table displayed some really old looking baseball cards—an odd size—unlike anything I had seen before. Interesting names. Wow. Honus Wagner. I’ve heard that name somewhere before. Card looks old. A couple of creases. But what if? And beyond this handful of odd rectangular cards, there were comics and cards everywhere I scanned.

So why was he selling, I asked. He chuckled. Something about his wife wanting it all out of here, wanting to fix up the house. That sounded legitimate. I ventured a question about the price. It was, he quickly reminded, a remarkable collection. $2,500. Good gosh. I did not have that kind of money sitting around. Four children at home will do that to you. Maybe he would consider something less.

“Well, if you buy it today, I would sell it for $2,000. We have to get it out of here. And I have a truck I could load it in and take it to your house.”

The deal dangled in the air. My mind whirred. There were other callers asking about the ad. Honus Wagner. EBay. I could go to a nearby bank and get a cash advance off my credit card. I should probably call my wife, Joy, before borrowing that amount of money. Tens of thousands of cards. Mickey Mantle. Sleeved comic books by the case. Really old cards. Honus Wagner. No need to worry Joy with all that stressful financial stuff. Maybe she won’t ask what it cost anyway. A signed Mickey Mantle. You’ve done great on eBay. Sure it’s a huge risk, but what if…

Two hours later, a truck pulled into our driveway, and the seller and I proceeded to fill my garage with a “Huge Lot of Comics and Baseball Memorabilia.”

My kids were curious. I told them the story. Dad had found this great deal. Joy was curious. I told her the story. Her eBay husband had found this great deal. How much did it cost? Well, it’s some really, really cool stuff. Oh look, I think I see a deer in the backyard.

I could not wait to research my treasure. The initial information was encouraging. Those odd rectangular cards were Tobacco cards, included in packs of cigarettes. They featured various sports figures, including Honus Wagner. An original Tobacco Card T206 Honus Wagner even in poor condition will pay off your house mortgage. I soon discovered the unsettling reality known as reproductions.

I researched and studied and put the cards under a microscope and read some more, discovering what you have guessed by now. My tobacco cards were not originals. The comics were originals and in great condition, but the comic market had just taken quite a tumble. They looked more valuable than they were. I had tens of thousands of baseball cards, but only tens of them had any reasonable value. The most valuable ones of them were not in the sets. That’s odd. I wonder how that could have happened?

After dozens of hours of research, creating eBay listings and negotiating with an out-of-state collector, I sold everything for a total of $987. That’s right. I forfeited hours and hours of time with my kids in order to lose more than $1,000, money we desperately needed for other things. I felt really stupid. I had been exposed as…

Wrong. Really wrong. On many levels.

I was wrong about the value of the baseball memorabilia. I was wrong about how much I knew. I was wrong about hiding the purchase from my wife. I was wrong about not getting counsel from someone who could have helped me evaluate the “amazing” deal.

I have been wrong about a lot of things. In fact, the subtitle of this book could be “Endlessly Entertaining Stories of Roger’s Errors and Ineptitude.” I am wrong, and have been wrong, about things far more important than baseball cards and comics. Of course, I’ve also been right before. I’d love to tell you about some spectacular eBay sales I have made. Perhaps one or two will show up in a later chapter. Sometimes, I am right. Sometimes I have a right idea. Sometimes I think the right thing. Sometimes I do the right thing. Sometimes I say the right thing to my wife. Sometimes.

So I’m partly right.

Which means I am partly wrong.

I don’t know about you, but I hate being wrong. I hate being ignorant. I hate looking silly or stupid. I hate choices that hurt other people. I hate to guide people in the wrong direction. I hate to make mistakes. I hate blind spots. I hate speaking words that wound my children or my wife. I hate admitting that I’m wrong. I hate people knowing that I am wrong.

Being wrong is depressing, frustrating, embarrassing, and damaging. It divides, discourages, worries and burdens. I try to avoid it. I try to hide it. I try to fix it. I try to downplay it. Nothing good comes from being wrong. For most of my life, that is what I believed.

But I was wrong.

While reading the Bible recently, I listened in on a conversation Jesus had with his first followers, and a switch flipped. I noticed something I had walked right by dozens of times before. It launched a journey through the pages of the Bible that somehow made partly wrong feel more like a blessing than a curse. An opportunity rather than a liability. A gift from God rather than an obstacle for God.

Wrestling through the biblical narrative and my own experience, here is what I have come to believe:

Partly wrong can’t be avoided, and that’s all right.
Partly wrong is the soil in which grace, love and humility grow best..
Partly wrong opens the door for deeper relationships and community.
Partly wrong is the classroom for learning and growth
Partly wrong does not deter God from blessing others through you.
Partly wrong gives you credibility and hope when talking to someone about Jesus.
Partly wrong answers some perplexing questions.
Partly wrong is often what God uses to get us right.

I am aware of the tension I raise with these claims. I am partly wrong. Every author is. I am inviting you, then, into a reading journey in which you wrestle with where I am wrong and where I am right. You could even make an adventure of it, scanning my words for the places where I am wrong. You could pencil a “W” next to a wrong statement and an “R” next to a right one. Pencil in hand or not, I invite you to read and to wrestle with ideas that have substantially changed my thinking and choices.

So, what is that Jesus conversation that changed my entire view of being wrong?


[For each weekday of the month of July (and Aug. 1-3), I am blogging a chapter from my book, Partly Wrong, to be published this fall. In the comments section, I welcome any feedback that will help to make it a better chapter.]


[Feature photo by terj57 at]


  1. Jenny Martin

    Such a freeing perspective that gives hope-that it’s ok to be “partly wrong”… and that God can use us in spite of that reality.

    1. Post
  2. Joy

    I had forgotten that those baseball cards cost $2,000 !!! Yikes! But about chapter 1 … I’ve personally seen the freedom in you as you have humbly walked out being partly wrong. I know the struggle to be right is real and I believe your story is going to give freedom to many others to be honest and humble and begin looking at others with eyes of love and compassion instead of judgment and assumptions. Keep it going …start the movement, “Partly Wrong” !

  3. Brenda Thompson

    Roger, I can’t find much wrong with your writing 😉 … (seriously). And the concept of being partly wrong has so many possible levels to explore … I look forward to reading more!

  4. Amy Dansereau

    Roger, I enjoyed this so much! I read through the start of chapter one with a smile on my face because, let’s face it, someone else’s partly wrong helps to realize you’re not alone in your own partly wrongs. Coming from a childhood church where perceived perfection was the norm, your honesty about your own brokenness was a life changing lesson for both JP and me. Through the rest I found myself just nodding my head, easily relating to it all. I always enjoy and learn so much from your humor, honesty and knowledge in bringing it back around to the word of God. Your writing and teaching is a true blessing. Thank you!

    1. Post
      Roger Martin

      Well, Amy, if that partly wrong story brought a smile to your face, you can expect to be smiling in the chapters ahead. You guys have always been so encouraging to us, and I’m grateful.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.